This article originally appeared in MediaPost on November 3, 2026. Republished with permission.

Within moments of the final out that made the Milwaukee Brewers World Series champions I was on the phone with my dad and we spent five minutes just …crying. As a Brewers fan all I have wanted for the last 44 years was to go to a Brewers World Series game with my father. As a fan I know a lot of how the Brewers got to the top of this particular mountain, and it is not the story that people usually tell. The story is that Brewers, being in the smallest media market in baseball play “Moneyball” not having the money to spend their way to victory. That is true, but it hides a much deeper truth about the success of the Brewers organization, and that truth is that they do not limit themselves to a single path to winning. They are not chasing a specific way of reaching a goal, no they are focused on simply reaching that goal.Â
Media, like baseball, is divided about how to achieve its goal. That division plays out in several places like brand vs. performance, but also in-house vs. agency. Of course, it makes sense because resources are limited and you will never have the budget you want. I have been on both sides of this particular divide. I started my media career as part of an in-house media team, went to several agencies, went back in-house, and now I am back at an agency. I can say with absolute certainty there are very real differences between working in-house and working at an agency.
When you are in-house you have a deep contextual knowledge of not just your company, but also the industry that your company works in as well. Beyond that being inside the organization you are able to see the different connecting points of the different functions of that organization; you see how product connects to media, connects to finance, connects to operations, and so on. But there are downsides, because being within an organization you can have a very narrow view, especially in media …you might miss the really smart things that are being done outside of your organization. Also, it has to be mentioned that in-house comes usually with a large amount of hierarchy and multiple layers of approvals to do anything.
Agencies by contrast are focused on marketing, and whatever area of marketing they focus on. They usually have exposure to a wide range of industries or organizations if they work in a particular industry and that wide exposure shows itself in being able to see what works in a lot of different places. That wide net also gives agencies a lot of different opportunities to test different media channels, strategies, and tactics. The tradeoff being the distance that agencies have from their clients’ financials and at times agencies lack a clear view of the politics of a decision within an organization.
So, which is better? Well, the answer goes back to the Brewers and how they win …they beat you by having the right players in the right roles. They can string together hits, they can run the base paths, they can hit homeruns, they can pitch, and they can play defense. As are a lot of things as it is baseball, so should it be elsewhere, because the question is not should we use an agency OR an in-house team. No, the question should be how we get the best from both of them working together by understanding what each does well and where each of their blind spots are.
Want more on this topic? Check out Beyond build vs. buy: finding the agency model that actually supports your team by Unlock’s Chief Marketing Officer, Shannon Curran.